Meet our #tikituesdays masterminds

Cardinal bartenders Baylee Pruitt and Chris Resnick are the wizards behind the weekly oasis known as Tiki Tuesdays. You’ll find this couple behind the bar every Tuesday night, shaking up tropical delights like Cobra Fang, Traditional Family Voodoo and Montego Babe, using fresh fruits and ingredients that they've made from scratch. The garnishes are just as spectacular — you can’t not Instagram their gorgeous drinks.

Their love for tiki runs deep, and not just at Cardinal. At home, they have more rums than most bars do, they stalk tiki treasures online and sometimes they serve drinks out of a giant conch-shaped vessel. No big deal.

OK, let’s talk tiki with these two.

You guys are really into tiki, so much so that you got matching pineapple tattoos a couple months ago. What’s the story?

CHRIS RESNICK: We woke up one day and we just really wanted to get tattoos, and we kind of wanted to get the same thing. It was right after Tiki Tuesday and we were still on a high from the night before. 

BAYLEE PRUITT: I said, "What if we got pineapples?" and Chris said, "Yesss."

Yeah, those are very real.

What got you hooked on tiki drinks in the first place?

CR: The fact that they weren't super staunchy and boring. 

BP: Yeah, they're silly and over-the-top.

CR: I think it mostly stems from rum more than anything. I was almost always a whiskey drinker, but the more tiki drinks I make, the more I find how much I enjoy rum. A lot of people don't really think they like rum. They've only had bad stuff and made terrible mistakes when they were 16 years old.

BP: I was one of those people. But now we drink rum all the time. At home, it's our go to liquor. 

When you started Tiki Tuesdays at Cardinal, there was just vodka and gin to work with — no rum yet. What’s the trick for using something other than rum successfully in a tiki drink?

CR: Making it taste like rum, mostly.

No such thing as too much garnish.

Baylee cuts each of these skulls and snakes by hand.

Is it possible to make a tiki drink with gin?

CR: Gin will actually be a really fun challenge. Tea goes really well with gin. Then something probably with cream, and maybe orange? We usually never know until we get here. 

What’s your favorite Tiki Tuesday cocktail?

CR: My favorite is the Jungle Bird, which is a classic cocktail usually made with a really deep Black Strap rum, a dark rum. So, (our version) doesn't taste quite as full as a regular one, but it's still really nice with our housemade bitter liqueur. Actually, ours is a little easier to drink than a regular Jungle Bird.

BP: My favorite one to make would probably be the Seabag, which has coconut milk, cinnamon and passion fruit, and toasted coconut shavings. I make the coconut milk, and that process is really fun and it makes the cocktail super fresh.  

Tiki mugs on loan from Baylee and Chris' personal collection.

C-caw! It's a Jungle Bird.

What’s the key to a good tiki drink?

CR: Balance.

BP: And not too sweet.

CR: Tiki drinks typically have three to nine ingredients, so there can be a lot of stuff in there, and you want to be able to taste every flavor.

Speaking of ingredients, which ones do you make from scratch?

CR: Falernum (an almond-ginger-lime syrup), coconut milk, cinnamon syrup, black pepper syrup, strawberry syrup, ginger syrup. 

 Order punch for the table and Baylee and Chris will blow your mind with this cool skull bowl. 

What do people love about your Tiki Tuesday drinks?

BP: Definitely the orange-rind skulls that I spend hours carving! Garnishing is just a huge part of a tiki cocktail. It's as important as any other part of the cocktail. I'm getting much faster at the skulls.

CR: Yeah, she can do around 50 in an hour.

BP: Which doesn't sound like a lot, but it is! 

Your garnish game is strong. And then there's the cool tiki glasses.

BP: The tiki mugs we have at Cardinal, those are from our personal collection. We have twice as much at home as what we have here. We look on eBay, and shop at places online. There's this one company (Bespoke Barware) in London that's fantastic and we lust after everything they make. We do have one thing from them.

CR: It's a big, beautiful conch shell (for shared drinks). It's enormous.

What kind of rum is best for making tiki drinks at home?

CR: I like Appleton Jamaica Rum for most purposes. For a white rum, I would go with Barbancourt.

BP: Rum is great, as far as being affordable. You can get some really nice stuff for the same price as an "eh" bottle of any other spirit.

And, finally, where do you get your sweet tiki shirts?

BP: We buy a lot of stuff from local shops in town, like A.Z. Vintage and Cherry Canary. 

CR: I got a decent haul at H&M recently. They went tropical for spring, which worked out really well for me.

We're making whiskey

A copper ladleful of wash.

By far, the question we get asked most is: When will Cardinal make whiskey?

Usually we say: Soon. 

Today we say: Now!

Last week, we started making our first bourbon using entirely Indiana-grown corn, barley, wheat and rye. We've waited a really long time for this.

This is us loading 1,850 pounds of grain into our cooker, Dolly (as in Parton), one 50-pound bag at a time.

The cooked grain fermented over the weekend, and we'll distill it and barrel it this week, divvying it among a dozen new American oak barrels that are 20 gallons each.

Here, take a look inside the tank. That's the wash bubbling as it ferments. It doesn't look pretty, but, oh that smell. And the sound. Yes, it's our new favorite sound. 

Secret ingredient: Chamomile

The ins and outs of our favorite cocktail ingredients.

Secret ingredient:
Chamomile

A favorite of:
Andrew Wind, bar manager at Cardinal Spirits

Why it's worth it:
Chamomile is light and floral, with a wonderful fragrance, Wind says. It's a simple, subtle way to change things up.

How to use it:
Wind makes a chamomile-honey syrup for a Bees Knees, a classic cocktail with gin, lemon and honey (recipes below). The syrup tempers the tartness of the cocktail, and the chamomile is the little twist that makes the drink taste special. You can easily adjust the syrup's sweetness.

The syrup is also awesome in:
Hot or iced tea (especially green tea)
Any dessert/treat you would want to add a nice floral touch to
On top of pancakes and waffles!
 

CHAMOMILE HONEY SYRUP
Makes 1 cup

2 ounces chamomile (ours comes from Bloomingfoods)
1 cup cold water
1 cup local honey (more or less to taste)

Add chamomile and cold water to a mason jar.
Cold infuse for 3-4 hours, lightly shaking jar every 30 minutes or so.
Strain off liquid into another jar, removing chamomile (it will become too bitter if kept for too long).
In a saucepan, combine chamomile water and honey.
Heat on stovetop until melted and incorporated, then let cool. Keep refrigerated.

BEES KNEES
Makes 1 cocktail

2 ounces Cardinal Spirits American Gin
3/4 ounce lemon juice
1/2 ounce Chamomile Honey Syrup
Lemon peel, for garnish

Add all ingredients to shaker over ice.
Shake shake shake.
Strain into glass.
Garnish with lemon peel.

Drink Dept.: Sour Ales from Upland Brewing Co. (+ a giveaway)

We’re on a mission to drink all the good drinks. Let’s get started.

Photo by @indyhops

We know this guy who often shows up to dinner parties with a few big bottles of sour ales from Upland Brewing Co. He starts pouring a little here and a little there, and suddenly everyone is rapt and ditching their glasses of snoozefest pinot noir for these acidic, amazingly flavorful beers.

Sour ales are barrel-aged beers with tart, fruity and often funky character that comes from using things like wild yeast strains and fresh fruit. Upland's are intriguing, complex, rare, unpredictable — and incredibly fun to drink. Conversation pieces, really.

We wanted to know more, so we chatted with Caleb Staton, the sours director and former head brewer at Upland, to get the scoop on these award-winning beers. (He's not the dinner-party guy we mentioned. Unrelated: Caleb, would you like to come over for dinner?)

** We are giving away two passes to Upland’s Midwest Sour + Wild + Funk Fest this Saturday in Indianapolis, featuring sours from 25 breweries across the country. The 4th annual event is sold out! Learn how to win the set of passes at the end of this post. **

MIRACLE FRUIT. A ton of whole, unprocessed fruit goes into lambic varieties like peach, persimmon, blackberry and cherry — specifically, up to 3½ pounds of fresh fruit per gallon of beer, Caleb says. This is a huge part of what makes Upland’s sours so remarkable. If you’ve ever peeled and cut, say, a kiwi, you can imagine how time consuming it would be to prep hundreds of pounds of them by hand. But they do it and it’s totally worth it. 

Photo from Upland Brewing Co.

Fruit comes from local sources when possible, Caleb says. The brewery gets strawberries and blackberries from Heartland Family Farm in Spencer and peaches from Huber’s Orchard, Winery and Vineyard in Starlight. Some wild fruit is foraged, too. “We pay a guy to roam around in a van and pick up persimmons,” Caleb says.

Kiwi time. Photo from Upland Brewing Co.

Smooshing Michigan cherries into a barrel of lambic. Photo from Upland Brewing Co.

SMALL BUT MIGHTY. Upland is more devoted than ever to sours and it even has a separate brewery dedicated to making them, but it’s still a niche product. The brewery cranks out 20,000 barrels of beer a year, and less than 300 of those are sour ales, Caleb says. The phrase small batch gets thrown around a lot these days, but it really means something here. It’s what keeps Upland’s sours program experimental and exciting. 

Upland releases more than a dozen varieties of sour ales each year, but they all start as one of three base styles: lambic, a Belgian style aged in white oak; an oud bruin style, aged in white oak; and a Flanders style, aged in bourbon barrels. A blend, known as Sour Reserve, has taken home gold at the Great American Beer Festival.

Photo from Upland Brewing Co.

PLAY TO WIN. Upland’s sour beers can be hard to get a hold of, which is part of their mystique. You can find some varieties in stores (a 750-milliliter bottle is around $25), but most are released in small quantities via lottery. Five lotteries are planned for 2015, and the next lottery in June will feature beers aged on orchid and kiwi, among others (keep an eye on Upland’s social media and website for lottery announcements). If you’re super serious about sours, you can join the Secret Barrel Society to get first access and more bottles than the lottery route. Annual membership is $250.

BETTER TOGETHER. Upland’s sours have always been a collaborative effort. The brewery made its first sour beers in 2006 using spent red-wine oak barrels from Oliver Winery in Bloomington. That partnership still exists today — in 2014, Upland released VinoSynth Red and VinoSynth White sours, both which are aged on Oliver grapes, in Oliver barrels. “To me, that really showcases that the program has come full circle,” Caleb says. 

VinoSynth Red won Best in Show at the 2014 Indiana State Fair. 

Photo from Upland Brewing Co.

Upland is clearly having fun fraternizing when it comes to sours. It recently teamed up with Yazoo Brewing Company in Nashville, Tenn., to make a tropical-tasting, rosy-hued ale with kiwi and cherry, called Three Degrees North. Yazoo will release a companion brown ale called Three Degrees South. Another upcoming collaboration with Great Raft Brewing in Shreveport, Louisiana, uses mayhaw fruit, which is like the crabapple of the southern wetlands.

Upland's Caleb Staton, left, and Yazoo's Brandon Jones. Photo from Upland Brewing Co.

SHARE, PLEASE. The next time you head out to a dinner party, take a cue from our popular dinner party friend and bring sours. Sours make you a fun party guest, and even though they’re flavorful on their own, they’re surprisingly interesting with food, too. “In some ways, they open up your palette like wine would,” Caleb says. Pour them either at the beginning of the meal — they really shine with charcuterie and cheese plates, he says — or with dessert.

---

OK, giveaway time! Upland’s 4th Annual Midwest Sour + Wild + Funk Fest this Saturday in Indianapolis is sold out, but we snagged two passes for one lucky winner. Here’s how to enter: Take a photo of yourself with an empty glass. Post it to Facebook, Twitter or Instagram with the hashtag #soursplease and tag Cardinal Spirits and Upland Brewing Co. Enter just once, play fair and all that good stuff. And we’ll pick one winner at random at 5pm on Thursday, 5/14. Best of luck!

Photo by @robmyersphotography